

Jose Mourinho’s New Leaf
By: chris | April 22nd, 2009
Since arriving in Italy, The Now Average One has made it a point to annoy all comers with his well-worn ways. Top of the list has been Juventus, who have borne the brunt of his vitriol. And you’d expect, after the bianconeri fans were accused of racism against Mario Balotelli this past weekend, Jose to unleash a historic diatrabe against all things Juventus. But instead he’s done the unthinkable and defended the Juve fans. Sort of.
The accusations of racism are a bit confusing – some reports say that Juve’s fans chanted “a Black Italian does not exist”, while the Juventus fans have refused to apologize, saying their chants weren’t in reference to the color of Mario Balotelli’s skin and Mourinho, of all people, agreeing. And it certainly wouldn’t be the first time a stadium chant has been misinterpreted.
“I don’t think it’s racism,” Mourinho told a news conference. “It’s an ignorant, stupid, infantile way to show that I don’t like this player.
“Why? Not because he’s African, but because he’s good, because he scores against my team, because he dribbles, because he’s difficult to mark.
“If I can say something in Juventus’ defence it is that it is not the first time Mario has been the victim of these chants,” he said. “It’s happened at many stadiums and even at our home ground.”
Well, he’s half-right – which, I suppose, is more than we can typically expect from Jose.
The problem isn’t necessarily racism or Juve’s fans (feel free to take a snapshot of that one) but rather the problem is Mario Balotelli. It has nothing to do with the color of his skin, his place of birth, his name, his qualities as a footballer or anything else he cannot control. It has to do with the fact that he’s the biggest twat in world football. Or he’s at least under strong consideration for the throne. He makes even Cristiano Ronaldo look like a humble altar boy by comparison.
Matteo Ferrari, an African born Italian international, also seems to agree the aggression against Balotelli has nothing to do with racism:
“I think people whistle him apart from the color of his skin. He has to change attitude, and I say this as someone who can be like an older brother to him. There is a code in football, right or wrong, you cannot behave the way he has at that age. He will only end up making enemies. He cannot continue to look for trouble. His excuses of a tough past cannot be accepted.”
Marcello Lippi, the man who will likely never call him up despite his immense talent due to his attitude, echoed the sentiments of Mourinho, saying the incident on Sunday has been blown well out of proportion.
And this is why Balotelli has done more damage to Italian football than imaginable. His holier-than-thou attitude, unprofessional manner and deplorable antics – and not the sympathetically lovable Cassano “oh dear would someone get this boy some Prozac already” antics – force a blind eye to think the hatred is racist* – and for a select unintelligent few it may be – and thus gives Italian football, a crumbling giant as it were, another black eye it doesn’t need. Which is precisely what’s happened, with every acronym under the sun saying a stronger stance needs to be taken against racism this week in the wake of the allegations against Juventus.
* – If there is racism it should be dealt with harshly, don’t be mistaken. But the number of people, including Mourinho, who are claiming otherwise – along with Balotelli’s long track record at such a young age – leads us to believe that the issues weren’t race-related.
For years now Italy has been decrying England’s ability to unethically poach Italian youngsters, but maybe this is one case where they could do calcio a favor. Italy has enough problems – particularly if Mourinho starts defending the enemy.
![]() |
Soccer Forums | Team/International Results | |||
Subscribe
|
Print
|
Share
![]() |
Comments
-



This is a comment (and there was a lengthy discussion on the milan page as well.) that I made on the AC Milan Page, that fits well.
http://www.channel4.com/sport/football_italia/apr21r.html
This is the response from the Juve Ultras, for your reference.
I must admit, they have made some very good points. The question is, have we become so “politically correct” that the fact that you just dont like some person and they are not of the same color as you, it is automatically assumed that you are racist?
Cant we just hate douche bags on the basis that they are douche bags without being accused that you are racist for not liking a person of a different color.
Not sure what the exact words by Juve fans were, so I guess this is pure conjecture.
Posted from
United States

-



If it isn’t about race though, why are people apparently using what would appear to be racist chants? Why aren’t they just chanting (the italian equivilant) of wanker at him?
Posted from
United States

-



he is just protecting his back by getting the fans on his good side…
Posted from
United States

-



How is ‘there’s no such as a black Italian’ not racist?
Posted from
United Kingdom

-



the whistle was not racist because the juve fans did not whistle vieira, muntari nor chivu. they whistle at mario because he score goal and his super mario.
also balotelli is not black italian, his italo-ghanaian with both nationality.
Posted from
United States

-



I’ve always thought that there’s two sorts of racism: the one-handed-salute maliciously ideological kind, and the casual literal kind that everyone is.
The Juve Ultras might not be inherently “ideologically racist”, but as long as they use his race to attack him, even indirectly, they are being “literally, racist”. Maybe you could argue that that’s forgivable, but, as Rob said, why bring his race into it in the first place? It smacks of something more than just an innocent attack on his personality.Posted from
United States

-



Exactly what martin says…. how is saying ‘a black italian doesnt exist’ NOT racist?… the second you bring race into your insult or chant in a negative connotation, it becomes racist. If they wouldve said somethin about Mario as Mario the person then it wouldnt be.
And this whole concept of people who arent from the minority group telling the minority group what they should take as racism and not, is pure bullshit.. they dont have that right because they dont know what its like to be said minority group, they have never taken a walk in their shoes, etc..they cannot relate to their experiences..
and personally Im a fan of players like Mario who have this ‘i dont give a f##k’ personality…we need more like them in game..
Posted from
United States

-



Yeah, that’s BS. If you don’t like him, you don’t like him- chant about that. Call him an asshole, a wanker, whatever, but why make it a racial thing? AK is right. It’s casual racism and has no place in football, no matter what Balotelli’s personality is. Sorry, chris, but you’re completely wrong.
Posted from
United States

-



If other tifosi chanted ¨Camoranesi is not Italian¨ would that be racist?
Posted from
Spain

-



IMHO the Juve fans were looking for the quickest way to do some damage to Balotelli’s overweening pride. Italy is still a largely homogenous country and he’s had to defend his “Italianness” to his own countrymen on several occasions… so I agree with the poster above (and Mourinho) that the Juve ultras aren’t really ideologically racist but resorted to racist tactics in order to get into the mind of a player who has proven himself to be susceptible to such antics.
There’s also a cultural difference in terms of how blunt Italians can be. They’ll very easily tell you that you’re fat, short, brown, whatever and it’s perfectly acceptable in their mindset to do so but to the outsiders it can make them look like pricks sometimes.
BTW, to the guy who said that he wants more Balotellis in football, what the hell are you smoking? Not even Inter fans can stand him and there’s a good chance that his unsavory character will preclude him from the career that his talent should have assured him.
Posted from
United States

-



alessio: I really hope you’re not being serious. No, that’s not racist since “Camoranesi” is not the name for a RACE of people — it’s the name of a person.
Posted from
United States

-



From what I heard the chants were “Balotelli is not Italian”
Posted from
Spain

-



“Since arriving in Italy, The Now Average One has made it a point to annoy all comers with his well-worn ways.”
“The Toothless One” is wrong on 2 accounts. First of all, if he’s average, I guess that makes Ranieri and Spalletti the Sub-Par Ones (The D Minus Ones? The Lower Tier Ones? The Under Dwellers?) since neither has a win against him in 6 tries this season.
Secondly there are several people in the media, coaches and players in addition to supporters who are not annoyed by Mo, but on the contrary, are happy to see him and the breath of fresh air that he brings to the somewhat sterile Serie A. I mean, exactly what has he said that was not truthful and has not come to pass? He seems right on the button actually.
“Not even Inter fans can stand [Balotelli]”
Wrong – actually it’s a lie – as this person has been told several times, by several people that we Inter fans, in fact, do like him, his talent and his attitude.
__________________
Although I would consider the arrogance and ignorance that it takes for these 2 people, to think that they can speak for me or anyone. It’s like propaganda – which would describe the Roma Offsides pretty well.It’s very entertaining.
_______________
Oh and by the way, to use race as an issue (maybe not the only one, but an issue) for not liking someone is prejudicial, it’s stereotypical, it’s ethnocentric and especially – it’s racist. And it’s really stupid considering the fact that the “races” themselves don’t actually, scientifically/genetically exist.The fact that people are pricks to the Juve fanbase isn’t a free pass as their “response” to the closed stadium seems to suggest. Two wrongs, as they say, do not make a right. The Juve fan base had a chance to prove how great they can be by being better than the sheeple, but typically, they failed miserably.
Posted from
United States

-



alessio – Camoranesi grew up in Argentina, didn`t move to Italy until his 20s, and has said that he feels Argentinian. It`s not a very useful comparison in this case given that their circumstances are substantially different.
On what grounds can one say that Balotelli isn`t Italian – not by his place of birth, mother tongue, the cultural milieu in which he was raised, or even his legal citizenship … so think about what`s left in this scenario. To interpret such a chant in the most charitable way, it`s at least xenophobic and ethnically prejudiced.
Posted from
Canada

-



Chris, you are the twat.
Posted from
United Kingdom

-



Yes ofcourse its all balotelli’s fault. He has disgraced the reputation of italy by being targeted for racist abuse.
Posted from
United Kingdom

-



Could you guys read through? The supposed chants are conjecture and everyone who was at the game says the chants weren’t racist.
Posted from
United States

-



chris, I read your whole entry as well as multiple articles on this, thanks, and it’s not quite that clear. All the denials of racism that I’ve seen have been based on the faulty logic that to be racist the fans have to attack every black player all the time in this way. Both Mourinho and Lippi have framed their denials of racism in this way. Frankly, the “but some of my friends, uh, favorite players are black!” and the “well, if he hadn’t been asking for it….” lines of argument make me suspect that there really was racist chanting because it sounds like people trying to make the argument, “well, but they don’t REALLY mean it” instead of “well, what really happened is that he got booed like everyone else and just happens to be black”.
The articles I’ve read (reuters, not goal.com) report that the fans were singing “a black Italian does not exist”, that police are studying video evidence, and that Juve’s president’s statement admitted/acknowledged racist chanting. None of that is cast iron proof like seeing/hearing it for myself would be, but it seems that someone has reason to think there was a problem.
Posted from
Canada

-



OH MY GOD!!!! I cannot believe that someone is actually trying to rationalize this disgrace. The award for biggest twat in the world definately belongs to the author of this abomination & not Balotelli. I guess if Jose(second biggest twat) & the Juve fans(Known for their Racial Tolerance & acceptence)say it wasn’t racially motivated we should all defer to their opinion. Chris you are a fool & anyone agreeing with this article is an even bigger fool. What part of monkey chants & “there is no such thing as a BLACK Italian..” doesn’t scream of racism.NOBODY no matter how controversial he is should be a victim of such disgraceful mutterings. This is not the first time Italian football has come to the defence of their Ridiculous fans and judging by their denial, chances of an end to this behaviour are slim. Many concerned people have frequently called for tougher sanctions against Teams that harbour racist fans but the most they get is usually a 8,000 euro fine. HAHAHAHA, 8,000 euro fine would not make a dent in Jose’s wallet let alone the Juve club. Juve has been forced to play behind closed doors but that’s not enough; the sanction should be significant enough for them to become proactive against this problem. Living in the US we are always talking about how race relations are still an issue but every time i read stuff like this iam so pleased with the great strides we have taken.
Chris do us a favour and unplug your PC PERMANETLY, then go find a tall building and try to fly
Posted from
United States

-



K… why don’t you read some of the posts in this discussion before you grace us with your unique brand nothingness. No one is saying you have to love the guy or even respect him but the minute you make race the motivation for your dislike it becomes something heinous. By the way its not conjecture anymore, Juve was fined and will be playing in closed doors. So i guess it must have been particularly more offensive than the usual racist chants that Italian soccer tolerates.
Posted from
United States

Comments are closed











